The Power of Email Follow-Up: Why Most Businesses Lose Leads After the First Click

• by Sandy Waggett
• 9 min reading time

Let’s start with a hard truth:

If you’re not following up with your website visitors through email, you’re leaving money—and opportunity—on the table. Every single day.

I’ve seen it over and over again: A small business invests in a website, runs some ads, maybe even builds a lead magnet... and then?

Crickets. Because they never followed up.

Most leads don’t go cold because they weren’t interested. They go cold because you stopped showing up.

In this blog, I’ll break down:

• Why email follow-up still works (better than anything else)

• What kind of emails you actually need

• How to structure an automated follow-up sequence that converts

• Real-world examples from MSW’s Performance Marketing Program

• And how to stop losing leads after the first click

Why Most Businesses Lose Their Best Leads

When someone downloads your lead magnet, fills out your contact form, or clicks through from an ad, that’s not the end of the story—it’s the beginning.

But if you don’t follow up with them quickly and consistently, they forget you exist.

• They get distracted

• They go back to scrolling

• Another business follows up faster

• And you lose the opportunity

According to HubSpot, only 2% of sales happen on the first contact—and 80% of leads never convert due to lack of follow-up.

You don’t need to chase people.
You need a system that continues the conversation.

That’s where email comes in.

Why Email Follow-Up Still Works in 2025

You may have heard people say email is outdated, but here’s the reality:

• 99% of people check their email every day (often multiple times)
• Email is 40x more effective at acquiring customers than Facebook or Twitter (McKinsey)
• Email marketing delivers an average ROI of $36 for every $1 spent (Litmus, 2024)

It’s personal. It’s direct. And when done right, it nurtures cold leads into warm ones—and warm ones into paying clients.

What a Great Email Follow-Up System Looks Like

At MSW, we build email automation into every Performance Marketing Program because we know most business owners don’t have the time (or desire) to write weekly emails from scratch.

Here’s the structure we use:

1. The Welcome Sequence (Days 1–3)

This goes out immediately after someone downloads a lead magnet or fills out a form.

It should include:

• A warm thank you

• A reminder of the value they just received

• A personal note about who you are and what you do

• A preview of what they’ll get next

Example Subject Lines:

• “Here’s the checklist you requested”

• “Before you hire anyone—read this”

• “How we help business owners like you grow smarter”

2. The Value Series (Days 4–10)

Once they know who you are, you build trust by delivering value.

This includes:

• A quick tip related to their problem

• A helpful blog post or short video

• A client success story

• A mini case study or FAQ

The goal here is to educate, not pitch. Give them a reason to stay connected.

3. The Invitation (Day 11+)

After value, you invite them to take the next step.

Example CTA emails:

• “Want to see what this could look like for your business?”

• “Let’s build your strategy together—book a call”

• “Get your questions answered—no pressure”

This is where the real conversions happen—because by now, they’ve had 5–7 positive touchpoints.

Real Client Example: From Forgotten Leads to Booked Calls

We had a client with a great lead magnet and lots of downloads—but no actual consultations booked.

Why?

There was no follow-up. People would download the guide and never hear from the business again.

Here’s what we did in their Performance Marketing Program:

• Built a 5-part email sequence: intro, value, testimonial, case study, CTA

• Scheduled delivery over two weeks

• Added lead scoring to prioritize the most engaged readers

• Created a “reactivation” email for anyone who didn’t open the first few

Within 30 days, they booked 9 strategy calls—from leads that were already sitting in their email list.

But I Don’t Want to Spam People...

You won’t—if your emails are:

• Helpful

• Relevant

• Authentically written in your voice

• Spaced out and scheduled with intention

People don’t mind being followed up with. They mind being sold to without value.

When someone gives you their email, they’re saying, “Yes, I’m interested. Keep talking.”

Honor that. And keep talking—strategically.

What We Do at MSW (So You Don’t Have to)

If this sounds like a lot, that’s because it can be—without help.

Here’s how we handle it for our clients:

✅ We write your welcome sequence
✅ We build value emails around your services, FAQs, and success stories
✅ We set up automations to deliver at the right time
✅ We track opens, clicks, and conversions
✅ We adjust based on performance and engagement

That way, every lead gets followed up with—even while you’re working, sleeping, or out serving clients.

What You Can Do This Week

Not ready for a full automation setup? Here are 3 things you can do right now:

1. Write one welcome email.
   Thank your new subscribers and tell them what to expect.

2. Choose one blog post or resource to share as a follow-up a few days later.

3. Add a simple CTA to book a free call, download another resource, or reply with a question.

Even one or two emails can make a major difference.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Let the First Click Be the Last

If someone raised their hand to learn more about your business—don’t let them walk away without a word.

Follow up. Educate. Build trust. Stay top of mind.

You don’t need to chase leads. You need to nurture them.

And that’s what email lets you do—automatically, personally, and at scale.

Want Us to Write and Set Up Your Follow-Up System?

We’ll help you craft your message, automate your sequence, and track the results—so every lead gets the attention it deserves.

📞 Call us at 573-552-8403
Or book your free strategy session at:
https://mswinteractivedesigns.com

If you’re ready to stop losing leads and start converting them—this is the next step.

Related Reading:
→ Why “Just Post on Social Media” Isn’t a Marketing Strategy (And What to Do Instead)
Discover how to stop chasing likes and start using social as part of a full-funnel system that actually converts.

 

About the Author – Sandy Wardenburg Waggett

Sandy Wardenburg Waggett is the Founder & CEO of MSW Interactive Designs, a premier digital marketing agency specializing in SEO, AI-powered content strategies, and website optimization. With over a quarter century of experience (eek!), Sandy has helped thousands of business owners increase visibility, generate leads, and dominate their local markets through strategic online marketing.

As a Certified High-Performance Coach, Certified Maxwell Leadership Coach, and LXCouncil Moderator, Sandy is not just a marketing expert—she’s a trusted mentor and business strategist who equips entrepreneurs with data-driven insights and future-proof tactics. She leads AI & Marketing Mastery Training and exclusive CEO mastermind groups, helping business leaders stay ahead in the rapidly evolving digital landscape.

Sandy is also the author of the upcoming book, The Future-Proof SEO Blueprint: AI, AEO, and SEO Tactics for Small Business Dominance—a must-read for business owners looking to outsmart competitors and win in the new era of search marketing. The book provides cutting-edge strategies on AI-driven SEO, Answer Engine Optimization (AEO), and how to leverage AI tools to future-proof your digital presence.

When she’s not crafting game-changing marketing strategies, Sandy enjoys coaching entrepreneurs, speaking at business conferences, and empowering leaders to make bold moves in their industries.

🚀 Want to take your digital marketing to the next level? Connect with Sandy at MSWInteractiveDesigns.com or call 573-552-8403.

• Share on:
• WhatsApp
• Deel
• Tweet
• Pin it
• Messenger
• Email

---